Mercer County, Pennsylvania

 

13 heavily Democratic precincts including several minority precincts that usually vote 90% Democratic had most electronic

 touch screens down all or most of the day.  Of those who were able to vote on machines the machines were malfunctioning

 and some were unable to vote for the Democratic presidential choice.  Most in those precincts were unable to vote with

estimates of the number unable to vote as high as 4,000 people.  And of those who did attempt to vote in these precincts,

the undervote rate was as high as 75% in the presidential race. There was also improper programming of some machines in

minority precincts and some of the machines were switching votes from Kerry to Bush.   The machines were Unilect Patriot

touch screens, which also had major problems in other counties.

 

Findings of the Independent Election Committee, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, Feb 8 2005

2 precincts had undervotes over 70%;  another had undervote of 45%; and another over 20%;

5 otther precincts had undervotes over 10% and 46 precincts had undervotes over 5%;

vitruall all precincts in the oounty had undervotes over 2%. 

 

The Bureau of Voter Registration and Elections/ Board of Elections demonstrated remarkable negligence concerning Pennsylvania

Election Law.  Many legal requirements were violated.

There were inadequate checks and balances withing the Board of Voter Registrations and elections.

There was indadequate preparation and testing of E Voting machines.

Absentee ballots were poorly and improperly handled.

Emergency ballots were poorly and Improperly handled.

There were no secure ballot boxes at the polling places.

There were unacceptably high undervote counts throughout the county.

There were problems with straight ticket voting.

It was not obvious to the voter or election workers if the machines were working properly.

 

 

11/6/2004 Machine malfunction PA Mercer County. Glitches with electronic touch-screen voting machines occurred in about a dozen precincts in the county's southwestern corner.

(minority/ Dem precincts)   http://www.votersunite.org/article.asp?id=3720

 

 

12/9/2004 Malfeasance PA Mercer County. Amid allegations of mismanagement and incompetence in the Nov. 2 general election, James Bennington, Mercer County's director of voter registration and elections, will quit at the end of the year. Among the complaints being investigated are electronic voting machines breaking down; a lack of paper ballots to make up for the broken machines; electronic machines not registering votes; some paper ballots missing candidates' names; and poll workers making people sign their paper ballots. Most of the reported problems were in 12 precincts in the county's southwest region. Coincidentally, all of those precincts have a Democratic majority.  http://www.votersunite.org/article.asp?id=4208

 

11/11/2004 Machine malfunction PA Mercer County. Director of elections and director of technology said a computer software problem (not voters incorrectly touching the screen) caused Unilect Patriot touch-screen voting machines to malfunction in about a dozen precincts. They said repeated calls to the manufacturer failed to resolve the problem. On some machines, voters were required to vote backwards, starting on the last page of the touch-screen system and working back to the front page, in order for their votes to be counted. [default to Bush]   http://www.votersunite.org/article.asp?id=3793

 

11/6/2004 Machine malfunction PA Mercer County. Problems shut down Unilect Patriot electronic voting machines for all or most of the day.   Glitches with electronic touch-screen voting machines occurred in about a dozen precincts in the county's southwestern corner.

Accuracy of the Unilect Patriot machines are in serious question. One machine recorded 51 votes for president out of 289 ballots cast. The county's Web site reports that 51,818 people cast ballots but 47,768 ballots were recorded in the presidential race, including 61 write-ins. About 4,000 votes could be unaccounted for, mostly from minority precincts.     http://www.votersunite.org/article.asp?id=3720

 

11/3/2004 Machine malfunction PA Mercer County. Computer software errors caused Unilect touch-screen voting machines to malfunction in about a dozen precincts Tuesday. Some machines never operated, some offered only black screens and some required voters to vote backwards, starting on the last page of the touch-screen system and working back to the front page. Some of those systems never came back on line                 http://www.votersunite.org/article.asp?id=3674

 

12/9/2004 Fraud (misc) PA Mercer County. James Bennington, Mercer County's director of voter registration and elections, admitted he programmed some of the computers incorrectly and failed to test properly. One of the most significant voting problems found in the county was the recorded undervote, which is when the number of votes cast is lower than the number of people who voted. Across Mercer County, there was a 7.29 percent undervote.         http://www.votersunite.org/article.asp?id=4208

 

EIRS cases

************************

031283 11/02/04, 6:44 AM PST Machine problem shenango township municipal 3439 Hubbard W. Middlesex Rd. 724 528 2533, mercer County, Pennsylvania Touch screen machine; voter said that there is a review button; when selected names of candidates appeared but no indication of how voter voted on review screen; called over election official who said that "you're ok"; voter believes that her vote was not recorded. (or perhaps recorded for wrong choice)    Voter says many others having same problem; on elderly voter took 15 mins, still didn't succeed.


 

033237 11/02/04, 7:39 AM PST Machine problem Volunteer fire department; 415 New Castle Road, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, precinct where machines have been down all morning;

Complaint # 031302

 

033679 11/02/04, 8:10 AM PST Machine problem, 500 Darr Avenue, Farrell, Mercer County, Pennsylvania All voter machines in (many)Mercer County (precincts) are down; voters only got paper ballots after waiting for three hours. Ballots don't look legitimate -- instructions are blurred and hard to read, and voter doesn't trust the process. Mercer County District Attorney James Epstein has come down to different polling places in Mercer County to try to figure out what's going on, but there is no tech support around.

 

33933 11/02/04, 8:10 AM PST Machine problem; Insufficient number of ballots Wheatland, Farrell, Hermitage SW 1, Hermitage (votes at Kennedy Christian), Mercer County, Pennsylvania Machines at all four polling places are all broken because they are out of paper or are otherwise not working

 

034369 11/02/04, 9:25 AM PST Machine problem ???, Mercer County, Pennsylvania The caller, a worker for AFL-CIO, called to pass on a complaint they received regarding three towns in PA -- Sharon; Farrell; and Wheatland -- all in Mercer County. The caller received a call that the voting machines are down in these three towns and that they have been down for a number of hours (he did not know the exact polling places except for the one in Farrell, on Dora Ave.) and that there are no paper ballots

 

035421 11/02/04, 9:12 AM PST Machine problem John Hetra School, Memorial Drive; and Farrell Public Library, Roemer Blvd.; Southwest Garden, Darr Ave., Mercer County, Pennsylvania New electronic voting machines are not working -- none of them! -- and paper ballots ran out, so voters are told to come back later.

 

037245 11/02/04, 10:29 AM PST Machine problem SW1 in Hermanage PA, Hermantage, Mercer County, Pennsylvania Sarrell has computers down, district 241,322, 241,323 is not working, district, 241321 is barely working; Sharon PA preceincts 4-1, 4-2, 4-3 and 2-4 are down; middlesex is down, wheatland is down, delaware twsp has 3/5 computers down, SE1 in Hermanage PA has 1 voting machine down.

 

038671 11/02/04, 11:11 AM PST Machine problem VFD West Middlesex, Mercer County, Pennsylvania complaint # 033237; machines down

 

039186 11/02/04, 11:27 AM PST Machine problem Farrell High School and Farrell Library, Mercer County, Pennsylvania 1 1/2 hours before got paper ballot; 45 people in line; told to leave and come back; not given option paper ballot

 

042256 11/02/04, 1:27 PM PST Machine problem Musser School, Sharon, Mercer County, Pennsylvania Went this morning to vote and electronic machines were out. Stephen votes by paper ballot. His wife waited for machine to be fixed. While she was waiting, man from Mercer Board of Election showed up. He told stephens wife that none of the paper votes would count because they weren't sealed properly - his wife is very upset.

 

046290 11/02/04, 3:54 PM PST Machine problem Case Avenue School, Sharon, Mercer County, Pennsylvania After caller voted, a screen appeared that showed all of his selections. All of his candidates appeared except for his vote for a presidential candidate. Caller tried several times to go back and cast another vote for a presidential candidate but could not get his selection to register on the machine. After speaking with his wife and daughter, caller discovered that they had also had the same problem,

 


11/04/04  Machine Problem, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, Reported via e-mail: I thought you should know about my experiences on Nov. 2. I was a field organizer for the Kerry/Edwards Campaign in Mercer County, Pennsylvania, and I witnessed severe problems with the voting system there. The following is a brief summary: 1. Thirteen precincts encountered complete or partial failures of electronic voting machines. Many of these machines were deemed "unrepairable" be technicians, and were out of service all day long. All of them were in Democratic-majority precincts. Many of them were in African-American precincts that have historically voted up to 90% in favor of democrats. 2. Of these precincts, many of them lacked paper-ballot backups, and those that had paper ballots were unprepared to handle them, often issuing improper or illegal instructions.

3. Countless numbers of people were told to go home once, then returned later in the day, hoping that the system would have been fixed, and were told to go home again. Some even went to vote three times and were told to go home each time. There is no way to accurately estimate how many people simply never got to vote, but it is at least in the hundreds, if not thousands.

 4. Out of 51,800 voters who signed in to vote on the electronic machines, only 47,700 actual votes for president were registered. In one highly-democratic precinct, Farrell 1-2, with very low official turnout, only 289 people signed in to vote, but only 48 of them actually succeeded in registering votes for president (45 for Kerry, 3 for Bush). This points to a reasonable estimate that nearly 4,000 votes in the county were not recorded. Again, it appears that most of this disenfranchisement occurred in democratic-majority precincts. Since Pennsylvania was won by Kerry/Edwards, it has been difficult to get the proper degree of attention focused on this problem. However, the fact that these events did not directly affect the outcome of the election should not distract anyone from the fact that what happened in Mercer County was a complete disaster and a total disgrace. From their comments in the local papers, it appears that Mercer County's election officials fail to understand the gravity of 4000 lost votes and the disastrous affect that can have on peoples' faith in democracy. Such accidents cannot be swept under the rug. Anything short of a complete investigation into this matter should be unacceptable, and will be seen as unacceptable by the residents of Mercer County. Any pressure you can bring to bear to see that a full investigation goes forward will be greatly appreciated. Please call or write back. I have a stack of signed complaints that our office collected on Election Day. I am willing to help in any way to expose all the facts regarding this important matter.

www.votersunite.org/electionproblems.asp?sort=date&selectstate=PA&selectproblemtype=ALL

 

11/06/04  The Farrell municipal building poll precinct showed an extremely low turnout.  The voting machine recorded a total of 48 votes for U.S. Sen. John Kerry and three votes for George W. Bush in the presidential race. Lark said he finds it difficult to believe that only 51 people out of the 289 who voted actually cast a ballot in the presidential race. Countywide it would appear that about 4,000 votes could be unaccounted for.   www.vindy.com/basic/news/288078640794824.php

 

Beaver County, Pennsylvania, which also uses Unilect touch screens also had similar problems including high undervotes and vote switching.

 

The state of Pennsylvania has decertified Unilect touch screens for use in Ohio due to the major problems.